Skip to content

In or out of community of property? Your options explained

Marriage is personal, but the property system attached to it has very practical consequences. In South Africa, doing nothing is still a decision: if no valid antenuptial contract changes the position, marriage in community of property is generally the default.

An antenuptial contract, or ANC, is often discussed as though it is purely about protecting assets. In practice, the better conversation is about the life two people are planning together: family, careers, property, debt and what each person believes is fair. I want couples to understand the choice they are making, not simply sign a document before the wedding.

The short version

  • In community of property generally creates a joint estate, subject to legal exceptions.
  • An antenuptial contract can establish marriage out of community of property.
  • For modern marriages out of community under an ANC, the accrual system applies unless the contract expressly excludes it.

What happens if you marry without an antenuptial contract?

For couples to whom the ordinary South African matrimonial-property rules apply, marrying without an antenuptial contract generally means marrying in community of property.

That is why I dislike treating an ANC as paperwork for wealthy people. The real question is simply: do you understand the financial system your marriage will have?

What does in community of property mean?

In broad terms, spouses married in community of property share a joint estate. Assets and liabilities are dealt with under that system, subject to important statutory and legal exceptions.

It can suit couples who genuinely want that structure. The difficulty is when people discover its consequences only after a business problem, debt or major transaction brings the joint estate into focus. We want to avoid that by having legal clarity from day one.

How an antenuptial contract creates marriage out of community of property

An antenuptial contract allows spouses to marry out of community of property. Their estates remain separate rather than becoming one joint estate.

That separation can be important where one spouse runs a business, has particular financial exposure, or where both simply prefer to retain separate estates. It does not prevent a couple from buying or owning assets together.

Antenuptial contracts with accrual: how the accrual system works

The Matrimonial Property Act provides that a marriage out of community under an antenuptial contract is subject to the accrual system unless the ANC expressly excludes it.

Accrual keeps the estates separate during the marriage but creates a sharing claim on dissolution based on the growth of the respective estates, subject to the Act and the terms of the ANC. Without accrual, there is no equivalent sharing of growth under that system.

How to choose the right antenuptial contract for your marriage

There is no universally ‘best’ matrimonial-property regime. When I sit down with a couple, I want to talk about their actual lives: existing assets, debt, business risk, children, career plans and what each of them thinks is fair.

I would much rather spend time talking through those questions before drafting than hand a couple a standard antenuptial contract they do not really understand. An ANC is a legal document, but it starts with a family decision.

If you are already married and now want to change the system, the route is different. I explain changing your matrimonial property regime after marriage and the section 21 court process separately.

Can you change your marital regime after marriage?

Missing the antenuptial-contract deadline does not necessarily mean you are stuck with the same matrimonial-property system forever. But after the wedding, changing it is no longer a simple notarial appointment: section 21 of the Matrimonial Property Act requires a joint court application.

Couples who come to me after the wedding are often worried that they have made an irreversible mistake. Usually the most helpful place to start is not with blame, but with what they want their financial life together to look like now. From there, I can explain whether a section 21 application is appropriate and what the process involves.

The short version

  • Spouses may jointly apply to court under section 21 to change their matrimonial-property system.
  • The court must be satisfied that there are sound reasons, creditors received sufficient notice and no other person will be prejudiced.
  • If authorised, the spouses enter into the notarial contract regulating the future system on the conditions ordered by the court.

Why you cannot simply sign an antenuptial contract after marriage

An antenuptial contract is, by definition, concluded before marriage. Once the marriage exists, changing its property consequences can affect creditors and other people.

Section 21 therefore gives spouses a court-supervised route to change the system rather than allowing them to rewrite it privately after the fact.

How a postnuptial change works under section 21

The Act sets out 3 central requirements: there must be sound reasons for the proposed change, sufficient notice must be given to creditors, and no other person may be prejudiced.

That is why the application deals with more than what the couple wants. The court needs enough information to see the wider financial effect of the change.

What the court considers in a postnuptial application

The court may order that the existing matrimonial-property system no longer applies and authorise the spouses to enter into a notarial contract regulating their future system, subject to any conditions the court considers appropriate.

The notarial contract then needs to be executed and dealt with in accordance with the court order and registration requirements.

What happens after a postnuptial application succeeds

A section 21 application involves court work, notice to creditors and a notarial contract. It is therefore more involved, and ordinarily more expensive, than putting the correct ANC in place before marriage.

I would not give a universal promise about cost or timing without looking at the matter. The facts, court process and any complications can change both.

How a postnuptial contract differs from an antenuptial contract

I start by asking what you want the new system to achieve and why. From there, I can map the legal route properly.

It is not unusual for couples to realise after marriage that the default regime does not suit the life they are building. The important thing is to change it through the proper process, not through an informal agreement that does not alter the matrimonial-property system.

If you are still planning your wedding, the much simpler time to make this choice is beforehand. My guide to antenuptial contracts and matrimonial property regimes explains in community of property, out of community of property and accrual before you sign.